Comorat's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Fish Dodge]

Unoriginal, poorly drawn and just BAD.

Just another worthless clone of an already lousy "game". Your constructive criticism is as follows: Just stop.

[D-Fence the Game...]

Nice game

The good: 125 tower guards, 25 repair people, 10 Com Hub employees and full upgrades to the base.

The bad: Currently on level 35 and haven't had to fire a single shot myself since level 23.....though I have lcicked the airstrike button out of boredom a few times.

Overall: Admittedly it started slow...and it appears to be ending even slower but everything in the middle was fun :) I can tell alot of work went into this and the results speak for themselves. An overall good game worthy of the front page.

Nice job.

[::gunny bunny::]

Holy crap that PWNED!!!!!

Sweet, nothing more to say. Great game.

[XyzTris]

yeah right

You made this game but don't know enough about flash to make the window large enough to see?
Bullshit, stolen, thanks for trying though.

Starwin responds:

The problem was not with the flash but with the size on newgrounds actually. I thought I would make the game "more compact" but I did not check to see its effects.

I am however offended that you called me a thief, I worked hard to make this game and one mistake doesn’t dispute the days and weeks that I put into this game.

You need to think more carefully about what you type before you do.

[Earth Rock Hunter]

384300, beat that!!!!

Great game guy!!! Love the upgrade option and unlike alot of other "games" on here, this one actually got hard enough to maintain mmy intrest all the way to the end. Yup, I beat level 10, yay me. Love everything about this except the cheasy lasers that were hardly more than lines drawn quickly. Oh well, you can't have everything right?

great job though and congratz on Daily 2nd place. Though I do feel you got robbed.

[UTF's Cosplay Challenge]

Pretty good but it doesn't work right

Maybe it's just me but aren't you supposed to be able to click and drag the costumes to the model? As far as I know there is really only one way to click and drag and it wasn't working for me.

The music is cool and although the graphics were a little bit of a let down the whole concept is a nice twist to the thousands of unoriginal dress up games on NG. I'm not blamming this cause' there is obviously alot of work here but you really should fix the boo-boo I mentioned.

[Goldenass- Part 2]

YOU WERE ROBBED!!!!!

Fourth place my ass.....you low brow bastards wouldn't know good flash if it fell from the sky and crapped on your mom.

This rocks man!!!! Should have taken first place all the way. Oh well, at least it made front page. Great job.

[WeaponOfBushDestruction]

Decent game, shitty message

At least you didn't comeout and say something completely ignornat like "No blood for oil" and for that I give you credit. However in no way shape or form is this game worthy of the front page. At the risk of turning this into a political debate let me state the following:

1)American troops are being killed by people they are trying to liberate.
2)Being against saddam and Bush is oxymoronic, they are opposite sides of the spectrum.
3) War is great for the economy, it's the sorry ass protestors that are fucking everything up.
4)This has been coming since before you were born.

Nuff said.

[GTAMX - The flash mission]

Oh now that was just crappy

Sorry dude, but you spent more time cutting out the pics to use as objects than you did thinking of a good "game". I mean come on, how much fun can you possibly have with something that lets you park in one spot and still win? Crappy sound, basic action script usage, horrible collision detection and some half assed graphics coupled with a few screen shots from a game that has been on the market for years. I can't belive this got as high as a 2.40

Try harder next time.

[Tanked]

Very nice

I love this, its like combat tennis/dodge ball.
I could totally see this making it onto the market as a nice little 3 dollar game for your comp or laptop. There are only a few things I would change:

1) Customizable controls for laptop users.
2)A selection of BG music and the option to turn it off.
3)A description on game play, you figure it out pretty quick but that might be nice.
4)A bigger play field.
5)Some sort of reaction from the tank drivers when they get hit, a well placed "damnit" or "OUCH" goes a long way in the satisfaction level.

Great job so far, I cant wait to see the finished product. If you'd like some advice/help feel free to email me.