Comorat's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Monster Bash]

legit or not

This is kinda boring. The sound gets old fast and so does the gameplay. The graphics are great and the play control is simple. Its just not something I would come back to do again. Good quality work, just not my cup o' tea.

[SkyAttack]

Fucking PERFECTION

Now THIS is a game!!! Awesome job, you should have included some instructions on how to control the missles for the people that have never played missle command before, but I had a freeking ball with this. Great great job, this better make the front page.

[3D M-16 Shooting Range]

Not bad

Its not too bad for starters, definatly alot better than alot of stuff on here. A couple things though:
1)If those bullet holes are what makes this "3D" then you should change the title.
2)It never ends, never gets harder and eventually gets really boring.
3)Resubmitting things is lame, so you got a bad score once, big deal. Dont keep sending the same stuff in, you obviously know your way around flash, make something new.

[The West (game)]

Very nice....but....

There are a couple things that need to be fixed with this.

1)Some sort of check point feature for the desert navigation scene, MY GOD THAT WAS FRUSTRATING.
2)The music loop in the bar keeps repeating without end. Meaning if you loose the sound loop starts again with the first copy of it still playing, really really annoying if you have a 3 or more loops going at once.
3)The recipe for the margareta is WAAAAAY wrong. I cant say more on that here or I'll ruin the level.

Other than that its a very well made game, Im sure alot of people wont want to wait for it to load and will vote 0 so Im giving this a 5 right off the bat.

Great Job. Raaaaaaaaaaaaw hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiide

Footrest responds:

alright, thanks for the help. Where does it loop and overlap sounds? i made it stop and start again, I didn't experience that. well anyway, Margarita is wrong... hmm, i looked it up in a drinks book. Maybe theres different ways? dont know. And for the desert, if there were a checkpoint, it would be too easy, I think. If you look around some rooms, there will be answers ro solving things, actually for each level the answers are in it, just a matter of finding it.

[Asteroids Duel]

What the hell?

Why do I get the feeling that not only did you not make this but you uploaded the wrong damn flash? This doesnt have a fucking thing to do with death, or breaking things.....or anything else for that matter.

[Flash Lightsaber Tutorial]

Functional

I cant belive people couldnt figure this out on thier own. Its a sad day and age we live in now where nobody wants to try to figure something out themselves. oh well, you get points for catering to the ignorant. Well made tutorial, simple and right to the point.
Nice job.

[Curiosity Killed The Cat]

Nice job

Very very nice work, there is some decent talent wrapped up in this sick little cartoon.
Cat hunting range........LOL if only it were true.
Very nice job, you might want to consider compressing the file if you can. Did you use flash MX for this or some other version? If its differant where can I pick it up, flash MX is too expensive.

[The Button Game]

Oh come on people.....

Are you all really that easily amused that THIS makes the daily 5??? This could be crapped out by anybody with a half assed idea of how to do flash, and besides this has been done on the internet over and over and over for years.

Jeez...how you all disappoint me....
You dont even get points for effort on this one.

[>>> WRATH II <<<]

Very cool

Its nice to get a flash that someone has spent alot of time making. I have no idea why this took you a year but its still a very good game. I was a little confused as to what actually would make your kill-o-meter go up high enough to advance, and those damned angels didnt make it any easier, but all in all this kept me entertained for about 20 minutes.

This that weren't particulary great:
1)no music, a sound track would have been great.
2)after you beat the game the "bonus" level is weak.
3)When it comes down to it, all you are really doing is killing stick figures.
4) 15 bucks for a mouse pad? HA!!!!!!
5)No way to get back to the screen to enter your high score if you play the bonus game.

A very good game all around though, arcade quality if you compare it most of the stuff that ends up here.

Armegalo responds:

Thanks for the constructive crit...
More music = extra memory and will usually get annoying anyway - put a CD on :P
I did this in my spare time - wouldn't mind making something out of it. It took a year, because I have a job (writing games for other people!)